Post by Rob Caprio on Jul 13, 2021 19:57:32 GMT -5
All portions ©️ Robert Caprio 2006-2024
4.bp.blogspot.com/-gLfZi6IV_Vw/VHtygbi2hsI/AAAAAAABB5c/g3UH8-SSNvI/s1600/Ruth-Paine-Garage.jpg
The Warren Commission (WC) claimed that Lee Harvey Oswald (LHO) assassinated President John F. Kennedy (JFK), shot and killed Dallas Police Officer J.D. Tippit (JDT), wounded Texas Governor John B. Connally (JBC) and attempted to kill retired General Edwin Walker. The evidence supporting these claims is absent from the WC’s twenty-six volumes of exhibits and testimony however, therefore, this has left many questions for us today. I have asked so many questions in this series already, and now it is time for more.
******************************************
How did LHO enter the garage without being heard on November 21, 1963?
The WC claimed that after returning to the Paine residence on November 21, 1963, with the bag no one saw, that LHO entered the garage between 8 and 9 p.m. to retrieve his alleged rifle. The sole basis for this claim was furnished by Ruth Paine who said that she found the light on in the garage at that time.
Mr. JENNER - You had reached the point at which you said you entered the garage to, did you say, lacquer some blocks which you had prepared?
Mrs. PAINE - That is right.
Mr. JENNER – What did you notice in the garage when you entered it to lacquer those blocks?
Mrs. PAINE – The garage was as I always found it...
Mr. JENNER - How long were you in the garage on that occasion?
Mrs. PAINE - About a half an hour.
Mr. JENNER - Did you leave the garage light on while you worked in the garage?
Mrs. PAINE - Yes.
Mr. JENNER - You are definitely conscious, however, of the fact that when you entered the garage the light was on?
Mrs. PAINE – I am certain of that. I thought it quite sloppy to have left it on.
Mr. JENNER - Did you make any inquiry of Marina or of Lee Oswald as to the light having been left on?
Mrs. PAINE - No.
When Ruth Paine was first asked what she found when she entered the garage she said that it “was as it always was”, or in other words – it was the way it always was when she entered it. She is then asked later on if the light had been on and this time she responded on cue that it had been. Well, if there had been a defense attorney for LHO they could have simply pointed out her earlier comment. She said on the night of November 21, 1963, when she entered the garage it was as it always was, thus, if the light was already on as she later claimed than that must have been how it always was. Therefore, the claim by the WC that this was unusual on the eve of the assassination is sunk right there.
What did her odd comment “I thought it quite sloppy to have left it on? mean? Isn’t this an odd way to put it? Most would say that it was careless to do that, but the term “sloppy” is usually used in conjunction with a task or work. IF LHO had been in the garage and IF he had left the light on as claimed, was it part of an assignment? Is that why she said that it was sloppy to leave the light on?
What do you think of her claim for entering the garage at 9 p.m. or later? To lacquer some blocks. Sounds a little ridiculous to me.
As we have seen previously in this series there is no evidence showing that LHO ever owned a rifle or that he stored it in the garage as claimed by the WC. So this is really a moot point, but let’s consider their claim and see how LHO could have entered the garage without anyone hearing him do so. Ruth Paine was questioned about this during her testimony before the WC.
Mr. JENNER – Do you have recollection whether anytime that evening of hearing the garage door being raised or seeing the garage door up?
Mrs. PAINE – I have no such recollection.
Mr. JENNER - Do you have a recollection that it was down at all times?
Mrs. PAINE – I wasn't in the garage.
Mr. JENNER - Well, you entered the garage did you not that evening?
Mrs. PAINE - Except then; yes, at 9 or so. It was certainly down.
Mr. JENNER - It was down then?
Mrs. PAINE - Yes.
Mr. JENNER - You say your home is small and you can hear even the front door opening. Does the raising of the garage door cause some clatter?
Mrs. PAINE – Yes; it does.
Mr. JENNER – And had the garage door been raised, even though you were giving attention to your children, would you have heard it?
Mrs. PAINE - If it was raised slow and carefully; no, I would not have heard it.
Mr. JENNER – But if it were raised normally?
Mrs. PAINE – Yes.
Mr. JENNER – You would have heard it. And it is your recollection that at no time that evening were you conscious of that garage door having been raised.
Mrs. PAINE – That is correct.
Once again we see Ruth Paine state something that would sink the WC’s claim initially as she said that she was NOT in the garage so she wouldn’t know if the door was down or not. She then was reminded of the script and suddenly she was back in the garage that evening.
It is apparent that there was no way that LHO could have raised that door and lowered it again without being heard by someone.
Furthermore, he was not seen in the garage either.
Mr. JENNER - You did not see Lee Oswald in the garage at anytime that evening?
Mrs. PAINE – Did not see him in the garage; no.
This shows that the entire claim by the WC was made up and not based on anything tangible. There is no evidence showing that LHO ever brought a bag with him, that he owned the alleged murder weapon, that he stored it in the Paine garage, and that he entered the garage between 8 and 9 p.m. to retrieve it to take to work the next day.
Can any WC defender produce any evidence for the WC’s claim in this area? Can you show how LHO would have entered the garage without being heard?
4.bp.blogspot.com/-gLfZi6IV_Vw/VHtygbi2hsI/AAAAAAABB5c/g3UH8-SSNvI/s1600/Ruth-Paine-Garage.jpg
The Warren Commission (WC) claimed that Lee Harvey Oswald (LHO) assassinated President John F. Kennedy (JFK), shot and killed Dallas Police Officer J.D. Tippit (JDT), wounded Texas Governor John B. Connally (JBC) and attempted to kill retired General Edwin Walker. The evidence supporting these claims is absent from the WC’s twenty-six volumes of exhibits and testimony however, therefore, this has left many questions for us today. I have asked so many questions in this series already, and now it is time for more.
******************************************
How did LHO enter the garage without being heard on November 21, 1963?
The WC claimed that after returning to the Paine residence on November 21, 1963, with the bag no one saw, that LHO entered the garage between 8 and 9 p.m. to retrieve his alleged rifle. The sole basis for this claim was furnished by Ruth Paine who said that she found the light on in the garage at that time.
Mr. JENNER - You had reached the point at which you said you entered the garage to, did you say, lacquer some blocks which you had prepared?
Mrs. PAINE - That is right.
Mr. JENNER – What did you notice in the garage when you entered it to lacquer those blocks?
Mrs. PAINE – The garage was as I always found it...
Mr. JENNER - How long were you in the garage on that occasion?
Mrs. PAINE - About a half an hour.
Mr. JENNER - Did you leave the garage light on while you worked in the garage?
Mrs. PAINE - Yes.
Mr. JENNER - You are definitely conscious, however, of the fact that when you entered the garage the light was on?
Mrs. PAINE – I am certain of that. I thought it quite sloppy to have left it on.
Mr. JENNER - Did you make any inquiry of Marina or of Lee Oswald as to the light having been left on?
Mrs. PAINE - No.
When Ruth Paine was first asked what she found when she entered the garage she said that it “was as it always was”, or in other words – it was the way it always was when she entered it. She is then asked later on if the light had been on and this time she responded on cue that it had been. Well, if there had been a defense attorney for LHO they could have simply pointed out her earlier comment. She said on the night of November 21, 1963, when she entered the garage it was as it always was, thus, if the light was already on as she later claimed than that must have been how it always was. Therefore, the claim by the WC that this was unusual on the eve of the assassination is sunk right there.
What did her odd comment “I thought it quite sloppy to have left it on? mean? Isn’t this an odd way to put it? Most would say that it was careless to do that, but the term “sloppy” is usually used in conjunction with a task or work. IF LHO had been in the garage and IF he had left the light on as claimed, was it part of an assignment? Is that why she said that it was sloppy to leave the light on?
What do you think of her claim for entering the garage at 9 p.m. or later? To lacquer some blocks. Sounds a little ridiculous to me.
As we have seen previously in this series there is no evidence showing that LHO ever owned a rifle or that he stored it in the garage as claimed by the WC. So this is really a moot point, but let’s consider their claim and see how LHO could have entered the garage without anyone hearing him do so. Ruth Paine was questioned about this during her testimony before the WC.
Mr. JENNER – Do you have recollection whether anytime that evening of hearing the garage door being raised or seeing the garage door up?
Mrs. PAINE – I have no such recollection.
Mr. JENNER - Do you have a recollection that it was down at all times?
Mrs. PAINE – I wasn't in the garage.
Mr. JENNER - Well, you entered the garage did you not that evening?
Mrs. PAINE - Except then; yes, at 9 or so. It was certainly down.
Mr. JENNER - It was down then?
Mrs. PAINE - Yes.
Mr. JENNER - You say your home is small and you can hear even the front door opening. Does the raising of the garage door cause some clatter?
Mrs. PAINE – Yes; it does.
Mr. JENNER – And had the garage door been raised, even though you were giving attention to your children, would you have heard it?
Mrs. PAINE - If it was raised slow and carefully; no, I would not have heard it.
Mr. JENNER – But if it were raised normally?
Mrs. PAINE – Yes.
Mr. JENNER – You would have heard it. And it is your recollection that at no time that evening were you conscious of that garage door having been raised.
Mrs. PAINE – That is correct.
Once again we see Ruth Paine state something that would sink the WC’s claim initially as she said that she was NOT in the garage so she wouldn’t know if the door was down or not. She then was reminded of the script and suddenly she was back in the garage that evening.
It is apparent that there was no way that LHO could have raised that door and lowered it again without being heard by someone.
Furthermore, he was not seen in the garage either.
Mr. JENNER - You did not see Lee Oswald in the garage at anytime that evening?
Mrs. PAINE – Did not see him in the garage; no.
This shows that the entire claim by the WC was made up and not based on anything tangible. There is no evidence showing that LHO ever brought a bag with him, that he owned the alleged murder weapon, that he stored it in the Paine garage, and that he entered the garage between 8 and 9 p.m. to retrieve it to take to work the next day.
Can any WC defender produce any evidence for the WC’s claim in this area? Can you show how LHO would have entered the garage without being heard?